|
Research
Ian Thacker studies STEM teaching, learning, and teacher education. He uses qualitative and quantitative methods to investigate the role of attitudes, emotions, beliefs, biases, and epistemic cognition in conceptual change. He pursues three strands of research focused on: (a) mathematical skills that can be leveraged to support conceptual change about scientific topics, (b) the use of technology for STEM teaching and learning, and (c) teacher beliefs and biases that contribute to gender- and race-based achievement disparities in STEM. He is the recipient of the 2025 UTSA Presidential Award for Research Excellence, the 2025 UTSA COEHD Outstanding Graduate Advisor of Record Award, and the 2020 USC Ph.D. Achievement Award. His research and collaborations have been funded by NSF, Spencer, USDA, Gates, SSHRC, APA, and internal research awards.
- Peer-Reviewed Journal Publications
-
* Student coauthor
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Thacker, I., & Cimpian, J. R. (2026). The effect of promoting high expectations on teachers’ feedback to students. Educational Researcher. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X261492287
Experimental studies show that teachers’ feedback expressing high expectations benefits students, but it is unclear whether instructing teachers to emphasize high standards alters their feedback content. We randomly assigned 963 teachers to provide feedback either “as you normally would” (control) or to emphasize “your high standards and that the student has the potential to meet them” (treatment). Treatment teachers gave more detailed feedback on students’ strengths, weaknesses, strategies, effort, and math ability, with less positive ability-related feedback offered to girls and lower effort demanded from White male students. This study is the first to demonstrate that prompting high expectation feedback changes the substance of teacher comments. We discuss implications of promoting high expectations on STEM instruction and promoting equity in STEM.
- MacNaul, H., Cox, A., & Thacker, I. (in press). Attrition in autism research for challenging behavior: A preliminary investigation into parental stress and other predictors related to project completion. Behavior Modification. Advance online publication. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/01454455261495098
The increasing prevalence of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in the United States has elevated the need for inclusive and representative intervention research. However, attrition within research initiatives that includes autistic individuals who engage in challenging behavior remains understudied. This study examined predictors of study completion across three levels of engagement: consent only (full attrition), treatment only (partial attrition), and full study completion (no attrition). Participants included 182 caregiver-child dyads enrolled in a multicomponent study involving a behavior-analytic treatment and a severity tool research portion. Using retrospective data and ordinal logistic regression, we explored whether participant demographics, challenging behavior topographies, and parental stress predicted study completion type. Results indicated that child elopement and higher parental stress scores marginally predicted full study completion after a Bonferroni adjustment, while demographic variables were not significant predictors. These findings may suggest that caregiver urgency regarding specific challenging behaviors and higher perceived stress may increase research engagement. Routine examination of attrition patterns may support more equitable and representative participation in autism treatment research.
- Thacker, I., Schroeder, R., Shields-Menard, S., Ramirez, S.,* & Lopez, C.* (2026). Grounded relevance: How exploring soil data can promote perceptions of data relevance, data literacy, learning, and motivation. Journal of Microbiology and Biology Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1128/jmbe.00332-25
The ability to analyze, interpret, and draw insights from data and data visualizations is quickly becoming a necessary skill for success across multiple disciplines and careers. However, people struggle to make meaning from data, and traditional data science curricula fall short of emphasizing its relevance to underrepresented students. To create opportunities for meaningful applications of data science for racially/ethnically diverse students, we developed and implemented an online learning module focused on engaging N = 298 undergraduate students at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI) in an analysis of place-based soil data focused on identifying factors related to antibiotic-producing bacteria. Using a pretest-posttest study design, we found that students’ perceptions of data science relevance (Cohen’s d = 0.33) and microbiology knowledge (d = 0.39) significantly improved. We also inductively coded qualitative survey responses to explore how students framed “relevance” and how their perceptions changed from pretest to posttest, revealing that students perceived data tools as offering new scientific insights and applications across multiple disciplines, although changes over time were not significant. Automated text analysis of students’ analytical thinking using LIWC (Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count) revealed that students tended to use significantly less “discrepant” (d =−0.22) and “tentative” (d = −0.19) language over time, suggesting that they increased their level of certainty from pretest to posttest. We also found that students identified more relevant and specific environmental- and soil-specific variables for data investigations at posttest compared to pretest. Overall, our findings provide evidence that interdisciplinary and place-based approaches to microbiology and data literacy instruction support learning and motivation for racially/ethnically diverse groups of students.
- Derscht, A. S.,* Thacker, I., & Eitel, A. (2026). Should we tell teachers that they are (in-)correct? How personalized refutation text promotes or hampers conceptual change. Educational Psychology Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-026-10116-9
In-service and student teachers often hold math-gender misconceptions of female learners’ lower levels of mathematical talent. Such misconceptions are related to the math-gender stereotype that shapes how teachers interact with students and can contribute to the underrepresentation of women in mathematical fields. One method for reducing these misconceptions is refutation texts, which explicitly state and refute a misconception before providing an alternate explanation. Since refutation texts alone may not be sufficient to incite conceptual change among teachers, we presented them with an adaptive personalized feedback, which can enhance conceptual change effects. Yet, teachers’ identity may be related to math-gender misconceptions, which might cause worldview backfire effects where teachers double down on their original stance due to identity threat induced by an attempted refutation. In a randomized 2×2-pre-post-design with 336 in-service and student teachers, we investigated whether (1) expository texts, (2) personalized expository texts, (3) common refutation texts, or (4) personalized refutation texts were most effective for conceptual change. We found that personalized refutation texts initiated the strongest conceptual change for teachers who had held misconceptions at pre-test, but triggered the most backfire among those who did not. Findings suggest that personalized refutation texts effectively enhance teachers’ conceptual change when misconceptions are present. However, if misconceptions are not prevalent, personalized refutation text may lead to familiarity backfire; by repeatedly naming a misconception, it gains familiarity and becomes more credible than the intended refutation information. Hence, we recommend that personalized (refutation) interventions be adapted to individuals’ prior knowledge and misconceptions.
- Emenaha, U., Thacker, I., & Leihsing, S.* (2025). Invisible barriers: Examining pre-service teachers’ understanding of implicit bias in STEM education. School Science and Mathematics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1111/ssm.18386
Implicit biases are automatic thinking processes that influence the decisions and judgments we make about others based on their social characteristics, and teachers are not immune. The current study sought to develop an intervention to introduce the big ideas behind implicit racial bias to pre-service teachers (PSTs) and explore how this instruction promotes their understanding, awareness, and reflection on the impact of implicit bias in the STEM classrooms. Study participants were PSTs (n = 66) enrolled in an undergraduate Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) pedagogy course in a K-6 teacher preparation program at a Hispanic Serving Institution in the United States. Data for this study was collected from two cohorts of PSTs as they engaged in a three-lesson unit on implicit bias. Through qualitative thematic analysis of students' writing, class polls, and discussion board entries, data was triangulated and produced four major themes in response to the research questions of this study. We found that, through engagement with the intervention, PSTs developed an understanding of implicit bias, identified sources of implicit bias, reflected on their own biases, and identified potential strategies to mitigate implicit bias in their future teaching practices.
- Thacker, I., Schroeder, R., Shields-Menard, S., & Goforth, N.* (2025). Dirt don’t hurt: How relevant soil data can support learning and motivation at a Hispanic Serving Institution. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 23, 803–826. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10763-024-10491-1
To create opportunities for meaningful applications of data-science for diverse students, we developed and implemented an online learning module focused on engaging students at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI) in an analysis of authentic soil data. Development of the module occurred over three design iterations involving interviews with 10 undergraduate STEM students. We then implemented the finalized module in three undergraduate microbiology classrooms (N = 118) using a pretest, posttest, comparison group quasi-experimental study design to assess whether the module improved student microbiology knowledge, perceived relevance of data science, and motivation. Findings revealed that, after adjusting for key variables, the intervention group demonstrated significantly greater microbiology knowledge than the comparison group. Path analyses revealed indirect effects of the intervention through value and interest in STEM. We discuss how findings contribute to theory and practice.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Thacker, I., & Cimpian, J. R. (2024). An exploratory experiment investigating teachers’ attributional race and gender bias and the moderating effects of personal experience of racial discrimination. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 79, 102317. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2024.102317
The factors to which teachers attribute students’ successes and failures have important consequences for teachers’ instructional decisions as well as their expectations of students. Yet few, if any, experimental studies have been conducted to investigate the role that students’ race and gender play in how teachers make sense of students’ academic performance. In this exploratory experimental study, conducted with 413 mathematics teachers across the United States, we investigated the extent to which teachers attributed students’ performance disparities in mathematics to internal and external factors based on the students’ race and gender and explored the extent to which teachers’ beliefs and dispositions moderated their attributions. To do so, teachers were first given a collection of the student solutions with no gender or racial performance disparities. They were then randomly assigned to one of four conditions in which they were told that on this particular assessment: boys outperformed girls, girls outperformed boys, Black and Hispanic students outperformed White and Asian students, or that White and Asian students outperformed Black and Hispanic students. They were asked to report the reasons behind the disparities in math performance of these groups. We found that teachers attributed gender disparities in student performance to innate math ability, effort, and external social factors, whereas they attributed racial disparities in student performance to biological influences on intelligence, effort, external social factors or the assessment context. Teachers’ self-reported personal experience with racial discrimination moderated race differences in teacher attributions.
- Thacker, I. (2024). Supporting secondary students’ climate change learning and motivation using novel data and data visualizations. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 78, 102285.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2024.102285
National science standards at the secondary level currently recommend that students make sense of data constituting evidence of human-induced climate change; yet, secondary students continue to hold serious misconceptions about the topic. Thus, there is a need to create learning contexts that support climate change understanding, motivation, and data literacy for secondary students. The purpose of this preregistered study was to test an online intervention that presents novel climate change data and uses number-line data visualizations to support climate-change learning and motivation for secondary students. To this end, I conducted an experimental online study with 248 secondary students randomly assigned to either engage with the intervention, the intervention supplemented with number-line visualization feedback, or a control group. Findings revealed that the game conditions improved climate change knowledge and situated interest compared with the control, and knowledge effects were stronger among learners who expressed more openness to reason with belief-discrepant evidence. There were no significant effects of supplementing the game with number line feedback. Exploratory path analyses revealed that there were also indirect effects of the intervention on climate change learning, plausibility, and climate efficacy through epistemic emotions and motivation. Namely, the intervention was linked to these outcomes by decreasing boredom which predicted utility value and science interest. The study contributes to conversations around the role of data-literacy in supporting motivation for science learning and showcases an intervention that can be easily shared online.
- Thacker, I., French, H.,* & Feder, S. (2024). Estimating climate change numbers: Mental computation strategies that can support science learning. International Journal of Science Education, 47(1), 1–22. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2024.2307473
Presenting novel numbers about climate change to people after they estimate those numbers can shift their attitudes and scientific conceptions. Prior research suggests that such science learning can be supported by encouraging learners to make use of given benchmark information, however there are several other numerical estimation skills that may also be relevant in this context. This design-based research project aimed to identify specific mathematical skills that might support postsecondary students’ learning from novel scientific data. Concurrently, we also developed an open-source online science learning app. In three design iterations, we conducted 22 think-aloud interviews with undergraduate and graduate students at a Hispanic Serving Institution as they estimated climate change data, before being shown the scientifically accepted value. Productive estimation strategies included: tolerance for error, mental computation skills (rounding and arithmetically manipulating given benchmark values), and integration of prior educational and personal experiences. Two cases are presented, the first illustrates a student who used estimation strategies productively and was tolerant of their inaccuracies, the second illustrates a student who reacted negatively to feedback on their inaccuracies. Results implicate principles for integrating mathematics and science learning and showcase a learning intervention that embodies those principles.
- Thacker, I. (2023). Climate change by the numbers: Leveraging mathematical skills for science learning online. Learning and Instruction, 86, 101782. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2023.101782
The purpose of this preregistered study was to test an online intervention that presents participants with novel numbers about climate change after they estimate those numbers. An experimental study design was used to investigate the impact of the intervention on undergraduate students’ climate change understanding and perceptions that human caused climate change is plausible. Findings revealed that posttest climate change knowledge and plausibility perceptions were higher among those randomly assigned to use the intervention compared with those assigned to a control condition, and that supplementing this experience with numeracy instruction was linked with the use of more explicit estimation strategies and greater learning gains for people with adaptive epistemic dispositions. Findings from this study replicate and extend prior research, support the idea that novel data can support knowledge revision, identify estimation strategies used in this context, and offer an open-source online intervention for sharing surprising data with students and teachers.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Thacker, I., & Cimpian, J. R. (2023). Teachers’ race and gender biases and the moderating effects of their beliefs and dispositions. International Journal of STEM Education, 10, Article 31. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-023-00420-z
Background Women and people of color continue to be underrepresented in many STEM fields and careers. Many studies have linked societal biases against the mathematical abilities of women and people of color to this underrepresentation, as well as to earlier measures of mathematical confidence and performance. Recent studies have shown that teachers may unintentionally have biases that reflect those in broader society. Yet, many studies on teachers’ reports of students’ abilities use data in the field—not experimental data—and thus often cannot say if the findings reflect bias or actual differences. The few experimental studies conducted suggest bias against the abilities of girls and students of color, but the prior work has limitations, which we seek to address (e.g., local samples, no exploration of moderators, no preregistration). Methods In this preregistered experiment of 458 teachers across the U.S., we randomly assigned gender- and race-specific names to solutions to math problems, then asked teachers to rate the correctness of the solution, as well as the student’s math ability and effort. Teachers also completed scales reflecting their own beliefs and dispositions, which we then assessed how those beliefs/dispositions moderated their biases. We used multilevel modeling to account for the nested data structure. Results Consistent with our preregistered hypotheses, when the solution was not fully correct, findings suggest teachers thought boys had higher ability, even though the same teachers did not report differences in the correctness of the solution or perceived effort. Moreover, teachers who reported that gender disparities no longer exist in society were particularly likely to underestimate girls’ abilities. Although findings revealed no evidence of racial bias on average, teachers’ math anxiety moderated their ability judgments of students from different races, albeit with only marginal significance; teachers with high math anxiety tended to assume that White students had higher math ability than students of color. Conclusions The present research identifies teachers’ beliefs and dispositions that moderate their gender and racial biases. This experimental evidence sheds new light on why even low-performing boys consistently report higher math confidence and pursue STEM—namely, their teachers believe they have higher mathematical ability.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Thacker, I., & Cimpian, J. R. (2022). Teacher bias in the virtual classroom. Computers & Education, 191, 104627. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2022.104627
The purpose of this preregistered study was to examine whether patterns of teachers' race and gender biases found in prior research would emerge in a virtual teaching context. We asked a national sample of 989 teachers to evaluate student work pictured in screenshots of a virtual classroom showing students explaining their work. We randomly assigned the images of students depicted in the virtual classroom and tested whether the race or gender of the student would trigger biases with regard to teachers' evaluations of correctness, student ability, and recommendations that students be tested for gifted programs or special education services. We found no evidence of correctness or ability bias, but that teachers recommended male students more often to be tested for gifted programs and Black students for IEPs based on the same student work. We also conducted exploratory analyses revealing that school enrollment rates of Black students moderated teachers' ability and tracking biases.
- Thacker, I., Seyranian, V., Madva, A., & Beardsley, P. (2022). STEM faculty’s support of togetherness during mandated separation: Accommodations, caring, crisis management, and powerlessness. Education Sciences, 12(9), 632. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci12090632
The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic initiated major disruptions to higher education systems. Physical spaces that previously supported interpersonal interaction and community were abruptly inactivated, and faculty largely took on the responsibility of accommodating classroom structures in rapidly changing situations. This study employed interviews to examine how undergraduate Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) instructors adapted instruction to accommodate the mandated transition to virtual learning and how these accommodations supported or hindered community and belonging during the onset of the pandemic. Interviews with 25 STEM faculty at an undergraduate Hispanic Serving Institution revealed a wide range of accommodations they made to their courses and how they managed communication with students. Faculty strived to support student belonging with responses ranging from caring to crisis management, though some faculty expressed feelings of powerlessness when unable to accommodate certain challenges. The case of a responsive and flexible instructor is presented to highlight a productive response to a crisis. These retrospective findings point to strategies to support faculty teaching in virtual learning environments in the future; increasing opportunities for student–student and student–faculty interaction, supporting faculty in learning technologies that support these interactions and addressing faculty’s feelings of powerlessness.
- Thacker, I., & Sinatra, G. M. (2022). Supporting climate change understanding with novel data, estimation instruction, and epistemic prompts. Journal of Educational Psychology, 114(5), 910–927. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000729
Texts presenting novel numerical data can shift learners’ attitudes and conceptions about controversial science topics. However, little is known about the mechanisms underlying this conceptual change. The purpose of this study was to investigate two potential mechanisms that underlie learning from novel data: numerical estimation skills and epistemic cognition. This research investigated combinations of two treatments—a numerical estimation and epistemic cognition intervention—that were designed to enhance people’s ability to make sense of key numbers about climate change when integrated into an existing intervention. Results indicated that undergraduate students (N = 516) who engaged with climate change data held fewer misconceptions compared to a group that read an expository text, though their judgments of climate change plausibility were similar. Results also showed that the two modifications to the central intervention did not have statistically significant effects on knowledge or plausibility when compared with the unmodified intervention. However, we found that individuals’ openness to reason with and integrate new evidence significantly moderated the knowledge effects of the intervention when the intervention was supplemented with both modifications. These findings provide emerging evidence that, among those who are open to reason with new evidence, supporting mathematical reasoning skills and reflection on discrepant information can enhance conceptual change in science.
- Thacker, I., Seyranian, V., Madva, A., Duong, N., & Beardsley, P. (2022). Social connectedness in physical isolation: Online teaching practices that support under-represented undergraduate students’ belongingness and engagement in STEM. Education Sciences, 12(2), 61. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci12020061
The COVID-19 outbreak spurred unplanned closures and transitions to online classes. Physical environments that once fostered social interaction and community were rendered inactive. We conducted interviews and administered surveys to examine undergraduate STEM students’ feelings of belonging and engagement while in physical isolation, and identified online teaching modes associated with these feelings. Surveys from a racially diverse group of 43 undergraduate students at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI) revealed that interactive synchronous instruction was positively associated with feelings of interest and belonging, particularly for students of color, while noninteractive instruction reduced social belonging, but was related to more cognitive engagement. Small group and one-on-one interviews with 23 of these students suggest that students derived feelings of connectedness from their instructors, peers, and prior experiences and relied on their sense of competency to motivate themselves in the course and feel a sense of belonging. Two embedded cases of students in physics classrooms are compared to highlight the range of student feelings of connectedness and competency during the lockdown. Findings reaffirm that social interaction tends to support belonging and engagement, particularly for under-represented (Black or African American and Hispanic) racial groups in STEM. STEM instructors who aim to support feelings of belonging and engagement in virtual learning environments should consider increasing opportunities for student–student and student–teacher interactions, as well as taking a flexible approach that validates and integrates student voice into instruction. Future research is needed to further explore the themes of relatedness and competency that emerged as aspects of course belonging.
- Jacobson, J. G., Thacker, I., & Sinatra, G. M. (2021). Here’s hoping it’s not just text structure: The role of emotions in knowledge revision and the backfire effect. Discourse Processes, 59(1–2), 13–35. https://doi.org/10.1080/0163853X.2021.1925059
Refutation texts are designed to facilitate the revision of inaccurate knowledge; however, studies have documented backfire effects wherein respondents become less accurate when exposed to a factual correction compared to another. Here, we explored whether epistemic emotions mediated knowledge revision or backfire processes when reading experimental refutation texts that varied by supporting information. We asked 294 online readers to report their knowledge and attitudes about genetically modified foods (GMFs) before randomly assigning them to one of three refutation text conditions which varied in type of supporting information. We documented relatively low knowledge (19.7%) and attitude (14%) backfire across conditions and found no evidence of backfire effects among types of supporting information. All texts facilitated knowledge revision regardless of the type of supporting information but did not differentially elicit epistemic emotions. For those who revised their inaccurate knowledge, hope and surprise mediated the knowledge revision process. However, those who demonstrated a backfire effect reported significantly more anger and confusion than readers who revised their inaccurate knowledge. Implications for research and practice are discussed.
- Kennedy, A., Thacker, I., Sinatra, G. M., Nye, B., Swartout, W., & Lyndsey, E. (2021). Promoting interest, positive emotions, and knowledge using augmented reality in a museum setting. International Journal of Science Education, 11(3), 242–258. https://doi.org/10.1080/21548455.2021.1946619
Informal learning environments, such as museums, provide unique opportunities for science learning. They are deliberately designed to impact public understanding of science as well as shape visitors’ attitudes and behaviors. As a developing technology, augmented reality (AR) offers the transformative potential to support museums’ educational missions by enhancing visitors’ experience, thereby creating effective conditions for learning and personalized interactions with science. We implemented an AR-enhanced exhibit at the La Brea Tar Pits (LBTP) which aimed to reduce scientific misconceptions and explore the role of interest and emotions around science and AR technology as it related to learning and knowledge revision. Using a pretest-posttest design, 62 adults completed a brief AR experience that aimed to address two scientific misconceptions related to the consistency of tar and frequency of large animal entrapment. We found that participants had significantly fewer misconceptions at posttest than at pretest. Participants also reported higher levels of interest in science content than in AR technology and discriminated between the emotions they experienced with regard to science content and AR technology. Feelings of curiosity predicted knowledge revision and interest in both science content and AR technology. These findings may be useful for museums and other science communicators seeking to create AR interventions that support learning and conceptual change.
- MacNaul, H. L., Garcia, R., Cividini-Motta, C., & Thacker, I. (2021). Effect of assignment choice on student academic performance in an online class. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 14, 1074–1078. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-021-00566-8
Choice of assignment has been shown to increase student engagement, improve academic outcomes, and promote student satisfaction in higher education courses (Hanewicz, Platt, & Arendt, Distance Education, 38(3), 273–287, 2017). However, in previous research, choice resulted in complex procedures and increased response effort for instructors (e.g., Arendt, Trego, & Allred, Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education, 8(1), 2–17, 2016). Using simplified procedures, the current study employed a repeated-measures with an alternating-treatments design to evaluate the effects of assignment choice (flash cards, study guide) on the academic outcomes of 42 graduate students in an online, asynchronous course. Slight differences between conditions were observed, but differences were not statistically significant.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., & Thacker, I. (2021). A comparison of perceived and observed learning from professional development: Relationships among self-reports, direct assessments, and teacher characteristics. Journal of Teacher Education, 72(2), 138–151. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487119899101
The success of professional development programs has typically been determined based on their impact on teacher learning, without much attention being given to the data sources used. Large-scale studies have generally relied on teachers’ self-reports, whereas small-scale studies have included more direct assessments and observations of teacher learning. The purpose of this study was to compare teachers’ self-reported gains in mathematical knowledge for teaching with those measured by direct assessments. Quantitative analyses of the data collected from 545 teachers who participated in content-focused professional development programs indicated a lack of correlation between teachers’ self-reports and direct assessments of their knowledge gains. Furthermore, different teacher-related factors were associated with the learning reported by these two measures. These findings speak to the need to pay careful attention to the outcome measures used to evaluate teachers’ learning.
- Thacker, I. (2020). An embodied design for grounding the mathematics of slope in students’ perceptions of steepness. Research in Mathematics Education, 22(3), 304–328. https://doi.org/10.1080/14794802.2019.1692061
The goal of this design-based research study was the creation and evaluation of a mini-unit intended to foster perceptually grounded understandings of the concept of slope in middle-school students. Central to this unit was an innovative device designed to create a productive pedagogical space between student intuition for steepness and formal definition of slope. Nine students from a US middle school engaged with the design in one-on-one video-recorded interviews. Analysis of the data indicates that a majority of students appropriated the mathematics of slope to support their intuitive judgments regarding steepness. Comparing the cases of three students suggests conceptual learning milestones. Overall, the findings show that students’ successful coordination of steepness and slope demand that their analytical and intuitive constructions be surfaced and integrated multiple times throughout the learning experience. To support students in connecting the mathematics of slope to their perceptions of steepness, educators should plan for students’ multiple ways of viewing situations involving slope.
- Thacker, I., Muis, K. R., Danielson, R. W., Sinatra, G. M., Pekrun, R., Winne, P. H., & Chevrier, M. (2020). Using persuasive refutation texts to prompt attitudinal and conceptual change. Journal of Educational Psychology, 112(6), 1085–1099. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000434
We investigated knowledge and attitudes before and after reading refutation texts augmented by different kinds of persuasive information and how emotions mediated the process of knowledge and attitude change. Undergraduates (N = 424) enrolled in four universities from three countries read a refutation text on genetically modified foods (GMFs) and were then randomly assigned to receive additional information about advantages of GMFs, disadvantages of GMFs, or both. After studying, students reading about advantages of GMFs had significantly more positive attitudes than students who read about disadvantages. There was also a significant reduction in misconceptions; participants in the positive-oriented text condition showed the largest learning gains, particularly those who held more positive initial attitudes. Epistemic emotions of curiosity, frustration, hope, and enjoyment mediated attitude change while confusion mediated relations between pre-reading attitudes and post-reading knowledge. In addition, the direct relationship between prior attitudes and surprise was moderated by type of text. When reading about both advantages and disadvantages of GMFs, participants reported significantly less surprise when compared with those who read about either advantages or disadvantages of GMFs. To foster conceptual change when learning about complex topics, refutation texts may be paired with persuasive information that is aligned with accurate conceptions.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Thacker, I., & Quinn, D. (2020). K-8 mathematics teachers’ overall and gender-specific beliefs about mathematical aptitude. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 19(6), 1251–1269. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10763-020-10104-7
Teachers’ beliefs play a significant role in students’ academic attainment and career choices. Despite comparable attainment levels between genders, persistent stereotypes and beliefs that certain disciplines require innate ability and that men and women have different ability levels impede students’ academic career paths. In this study, we examined the prevalence of U.S. mathematics teachers’ explicit general and gender-specific beliefs about mathematical ability and identified which teacher characteristics were associated with these beliefs. An analysis of data from 382 K-8 teachers in the USA indicated that overall, teachers disagreed with the idea that general and gender-specific mathematical ability is innate, and agreed with the idea that hard work and dedication are required for success in mathematics. However, our findings indicate that those who believed mathematics requires brilliance also tended to think girls lacked this ability. We also found that teachers who were teaching mathematics to 11- to 14-year old students seemed to believe that mathematics requires innate ability compared with teachers who were teaching mathematics to 5- to 10-year-old students. In addition, more experienced teachers and teachers who worked with special education students seemed to believe less in the role of hard work in success in mathematics, which could have serious consequences for shaping their students’ beliefs about their academic self-concept and future career-related decisions.
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Robinson-Cimpian, J. P., Lubienski, S. T., & Thacker, I. (2020). Mathematics teachers’ bias against the mathematical ability of female, Black, and Hispanic students. Educational Researcher, 49(1), 30–43. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X19890577
Teachers of mathematics play a significant role in students’ perceptions of their mathematical ability and future career choices. Although a variety of studies have investigated teachers’ biases, most of this work does not distinguish between teachers’ accurate assessments of their students’ academic ability and their implicit biases. In this randomized controlled study (N = 390), teachers of mathematics were asked to evaluate 18 mathematical solutions that varied according to three degrees of correctness (incorrect, partially correct, and correct solutions). Gender- and race-specific names were randomly assigned to a series of mathematical solutions, and teachers were asked to first evaluate the correctness of each solution and then estimate the mathematical ability of the student whose work they had evaluated. Teachers displayed no detectable bias when assessing the correctness of fictitious students’ solutions; however, some gender- and race-associated biases were revealed in evaluations of partially correct and incorrect responses. When such biases occurred, non-White teachers’ estimations of students’ mathematical ability favored White students (both boys and girls) over students of color, whereas (primarily female) White teachers’ estimations of students’ mathematical ability favored boys over girls. Possible reasons for these results are considered, including that study design elements that might have influenced results, as well as the hypothesis that teachers from stereotyped groups may internalize the societal stereotypes that they are targeted by, making them more susceptible to bias that favors advantaged groups. These results suggest that interventions may be needed to address teachers’ subtle gender- and race-related biases regarding students’ mathematical ability.
- Kim, A. Y., & Thacker, I. (2020). A good sine?: Seeking math help using online discussion boards. E-Learning and Digital Media, 17(1), 78–93. https://doi.org/10.1177/2042753019874142
We examined asynchronous online discussion boards, specifically those that are unmediated by teacher figures, to identify characteristics of these spaces that support or constrain students as they seek help in mathematics. We analyzed 86 questions and 114 associated responses posted to two Khan Academy discussion boards centered around two related trigonometry lessons. The platform created a space where students could ask a variety of questions ranging from those requesting math definitions and explanations of math procedures to justifications for why formulas are true. However, crowdsourced replies to questions were delayed, sometimes taking more than one year for a reply to be posted; content of student replies did not always match the content of the questions posed; and the quality of the replies varied considerably, some replies were helpful or resourceful while others were incorrect or vague. These challenges seemed connected to the unmediated nature of this type of asynchronous online discussion board. We argue that this online learning environment demands additional self-regulated learning strategies such as awareness of one’s needs and the timeframe in which they must be met. We also discuss implications for research and practice.
- Thacker, I., & Sinatra, G. M. (2019). Visualizing the greenhouse effect: Restructuring mental models of climate change through a guided online simulation. Education Sciences, 9(1), 14. https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci9010014
The purpose of this design based research study was to better understand and build from students’ perceptual experiences of visual representations of the greenhouse effect. Twenty undergraduate students were interviewed as they engaged with an online visualization for the learning of the greenhouse effect. We found that, even though all students agreed that climate change is happening, a majority initially held a misconception about how it works. Upon engaging with the visualization, students made perceptual inferences and formulated causal rules that culminated in an improved description of how climate change works. This trajectory was supported with prompts from the interviewer to make predictions, observe specific interactions in the visualization and revise their causal inferences based on these observations. A case study is presented to illustrate a typical learning trajectory.
- Published Book Chapters
-
- Nichols, S., & Thacker, I. (in press). Assessment and learning. In T. Marshik, M. I. Axelrod, M. B. Leibham, & S. Hupp (Eds.), Investigating educational psychology: Pseudoscience, fringe science, and controversies (Chapter 15). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003510048
Assessment is the systematic process of defining, measuring, and interpreting student learning. It involves collecting information about what students know, understand, and can do in relation to learning goals and helps educators, parents, and students make informed decisions about instruction, curriculum, and student progress. Assessments can be developed by teachers or by individuals outside of schools, such as those who create standardized tests. Assessments serve several purposes: they can guide real-time instructional adjustments (formative), evaluate whether learning objectives have been met (summative), uncover students’ prior knowledge and gaps (diagnostic), and can even be used judge the effectiveness of teachers or schools. Given these multiple purposes, assessments are vital tools for teaching and learning; and they play an important role in how students, teachers, parents, and other stakeholders respond to student progress. The goal of this chapter is to focus on two core claims related to assessment, testing, teaching, and student learning. The claims we consider are: (a) teaching to the test benefits student learning, and (b) grades signify and promote learning.
- Thacker, I., Copur-Gencturk, Y., & Cimpian, J. R. (2022). Teacher bias: A discussion with special emphasis on gender and STEM learning. In T. L. Good & M. McCaslin (Eds.), The Routledge encyclopedia of education: Educational psychology edition. Routledge. http://doi.org/10.4324/9781138609877-REE185-1
An important feature of human reasoning is to make quick, knee-jerk decisions based on new information (Kahneman, 2011). However, some of this reflexive decision-making is shaped by social context and can ultimately serve as implicit biases that favor privileged social groups and/or harm marginalized social groups. Biases are ubiquitous in society and arise in many contexts, including in schools and the workplace. Even well-intentioned individuals who consciously avoid discriminatory behaviors can enact unconscious biases in their daily lives, which in turn can have serious consequences for marginalized social groups, and teachers are not impervious to such biases. The focus of this chapter is on the sources of and influences of teachers’ explicit and implicit stereotypical perceptions, and their implications for STEM teaching and learning. We would like to note early on that our aim is not to blame teachers for larger social problems, but rather, to call attention to pervasive stereotypes that exist in our society that can potentially shape well-intentioned teachers’ perceptions and reactions to their students.
Teachers’ perceptions comprise one of many factors that can influence students’ self-perceptions, beliefs, and achievement. Despite competing hypotheses from economics, social psychology, neuroscience, and sociology regarding different factors that might drive race and gender disparities in educational outcomes (such as arguments emphasizing biological vs sociocultural causes of gender disparities; Halpern et al., 2007), evidence from multiple disciplines is converging on the idea that teachers’ conscious and unconscious bias remain important factors contributing to inequitable student achievement outcomes, particularly in mathematics-intensive STEM fields such as computer science or engineering (for reviews of how teacher race- and gender-bias comprises one of many contributors disparities, see Ceci et al., 2009; Cheryan et al., 2017; Dixson & Rousseau, 2005; Wang & Degol, 2017, Warikoo et al., 2016).
This chapter provides interested researchers, practitioners, and policy makers with an overview of research on teacher bias and provide direction for those intending to create interventions to mitigate teacher bias and close these educational gaps. Namely, we summarize research on teacher bias including its history, current empirical research identifying teacher bias, the impacts on students, potential moderators, and implications for teacher education. Following this broad overview, we also include a section providing an in-depth illustration of how bias literature can help us understand a prominent issue: teacher gender-biases as they relate opportunities for women in STEM. Also note that, while the focus of this chapter is on teachers’ implicit and explicit biases, we also draw evidence from sources pertaining to other populations as well.
- Published Proceedings
-
- Thacker, I., Jin, Y., Koyuncu, I., Rios, A., & Niu, J. (2026, June). Bridging the data divide: An experiential learning approach to preparing students for artificial intelligence-driven careers. Paper presented at the American Society for Engineering Education (ASEE) Annual Conference, Computing and Information Technology (CIT) Division, Charlotte, NC. https://doi.org/10.18260/1-2--59686
- Vahedian Movahed, S.,* & Thacker, I. (2026, February). Interactive tools for middle school students’ AI literacy. In Proceedings of the 57th ACM Technical Symposium on Computer Science Education V.2 (SIGCSE TS 2026) (2 pages). ACM. St. Louis, MO. https://doi.org/10.1145/3770761.3777205
- Thacker, I., Schroeder, R., Shields-Menard, S., Lopez, C.,* Ramirez, S.,* & Alam, T.* (in press). Grounded relevance: How exploring soil data can promote data literacy, learning, and motivation. Proceedings of the forty-seventh annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education. State College, PA. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.47.2025
- Thacker, I., & Herrick, I. (in press). Data literacy for conceptual change: An integrated model with special applications in climate change education. Proceedings of the forty-seventh annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education. State College, PA. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.47.2025
- Thacker, I., Martinez, D.,* & Lester, K.* (2024). An estimation game to promote secondary students’ climate change understanding using data and visualizations. Proceedings of the forty-sixth annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 2075–2081). Cleveland, OH. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.46.2024
- Thacker, I., Schroeder, R., & Shields-Menard, S. (2024). Dirt don’t hurt: How relevant soil data can support learning and motivation at a Hispanic Serving Institution. Proceedings of the forty-sixth annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 1467–1472). Cleveland, OH. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.46.2024
- Schroeder, R., Niu, J., Malshe, A., Hum, S., Flemming, S., & Thacker, I. (2024, March). Enabling widespread engagement in DS and AI: The Generation AI Curriculum Initiative for community colleges. In Proceedings of the 55th ACM Technical Symposium on Computer Science Education (SIGCSE) (Vol. 2, p. 1938). Portland, OR. https://doi.org/10.1145/3626253.3635343
- Seyranian, V., Thacker, I., Madva, A., Abramzon, N., & Beardsley, P. (2023). A utility value intervention to support undergraduate student interest, engagement, and achievement in calculus and calculus-based physics. Proceedings of the forty-fifth annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (Vol. 2, pp. 464–473). Reno, NV. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.45.2023
- Thacker, I. (2022). Climate change by the numbers: How numerical estimation can support science learning. In A. E. Lischka, E. B. Dyer, R. S. Jones, J. Lovett, J. Strayer, & S. Drown (Eds.), Proceedings of the forty-fourth annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 2057–2065). Middle Tennessee State University. https://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.44.2022
- Thacker, I., Broadway, R.,* & Feder, S. (2021). Estimating climate change numbers: How tolerance for error can support science learning. In D. Olanoff, K. Johnson, & S. M. Spitzer (Eds.), Proceedings of the forty-third annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 1738–1743). Philadelphia, PA.
- Thacker, I. (2020). Numerical estimation skills, epistemic cognition, and climate change: Mathematical skills and dispositions that can support science learning. In Proceedings of the forty-second annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 1054–1062). Mazatlán, Sinaloa, Mexico. http://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.42.2020-166
- Thacker, I., & Rasiej, R. (2020). Mathematics teachers’ epistemic dispositions and their relationship with teacher instruction and student learning: A systematic research synthesis. In Proceedings of the forty-second annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 2126–2132). Mazatlán, Sinaloa, Mexico. http://doi.org/10.51272/pmena.42.2020-358
- Copur-Gencturk, Y., Du, H., & Thacker, I. (2020). Differences in mathematical ability beliefs between teachers and mathematicians in higher education. In Proceedings of the forty-second annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp. 573–577). Mazatlán, Sinaloa, Mexico. ISBN: 978-1-7348057-0-3
- Rodrigues, J., & Thacker, I. (2019). Refuting a fraction misconception: A brief intervention promotes teachers’ conceptual change. In Proceedings of the forty-first annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (Vol. 8, pp. 731–735). St. Louis, MO: University of Missouri. ISBN: 978-0-578-57791-3
- Abrahamson, D., Bryant, M. J., Gutierrez, J. F., Mookerjee, A. V., Souchkova, D., & Thacker, I. E. (2009). Figuring it out: Mathematical learning as guided semiotic disambiguation of useful yet initially entangled intuitions. In S. L. Swars, D. W. Stinson, & S. Lemons-Smith (Eds.), Proceedings of the thirty-first annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (Vol. 5, pp. 662–670). Atlanta, GA: Georgia State University. ISBN: 978-0-615-31397-9 [Author names are in alphabetical order]
|